Urban Housing Development Policies and Spatial Justice (Institutional Ethnography of Mehr Sanandaj Housing)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Department of Regional Planning, Sociology and Social Planning, Faculty of Economics, Management and Social Sciences, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran..

2 PhD in Economic Sociology and Development, Department of Sociology, Faculty of Economics, Management and Social Sciences, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran.

Abstract

Objective: The Mehr Housing Plan was one of the measures taken by the Ninth Government in the field of providing housing for low-income groups. In the meantime, Sanandaj city has been one of the cities where Mehr Housing has been implemented in its two urban areas - Degran and Baharan - due to reasons such as population growth, migration and increasing marginalization. In this research, considering spatial justice approaches, we tried to provide an analysis of the situation in these areas. China's main assumption is that spatial justice has not been realized and bio-urbanism has been marginalized in these areas. Investigating the housing situation in Sanandaj city is considered one of the most important issues of this city and this has created challenges for managers and urban planners, residents and owners. Mehr Sanandaj housing with a capacity of 7,600 units (built in Baharan, 5.43 hectares, and the total length of 20 and 14 meter streets is 6410 meters, and the street density in this project is 3.147 meters) was trying to create a space for the citizens to be able to solve problems and solve urban problems, especially housing. This project has created a situation that cannot be looked at from a statistical and quantitative point of view. Looking at this project from the perspective of stakeholders is one of the most important ways to look at the performance of managers and planners, contractors and stakeholders and evaluate the achievements of this project. This shows that the residents have had perceptions and encounters with the adopted policies and strategies. Their opinion about access to facilities, type of construction, space, etc. determines how spatial justice in Sanandaj city affects the living conditions of its residents. The basic assumption of this research is that sufficient and appropriate space has been one of the most important points that have been neglected in the Mehr Sanandaj housing plan. The way of architecture and constructions in these areas has indicated inappropriate space, lack of attention to infrastructure, and focus on the maximum use of land, and this is unequal compared to other urban areas. With this assumption, the current research aims to establish the institutional conflict of the residents with the policies and strategies adopted in the Mehr housing in Sanandaj.
Method: The research method is institutional ethnography. The data of this research are extracted from the experiences that have been formed in the struggle of institutional relations and institutional texts as the implementation of policies from above. Purposive sampling was used to select the people to be interviewed, and theoretical sampling was used to determine the number of people, determine the location of the required data, and find the direction of the research. Thematic analysis and emic model were used to interpret the experiences of the interviewees in order to achieve a critical reading of the formed experiences based on them and by placing them in the local context and situation. Interviews were conducted with 30 inhabitants living in Mehr housing located in Baharan town of Sanandaj. Also, the institutional documents related to the Mehr housing project (plans, statistics and information, the website of these involved institutions, etc.) have been examined, analyzed and criticized.
Results: The results show that the diversity and cultural contradictions of the population caused by excessive immigration and overcrowding of apartments created problems that put this urban life at risk. Many floors and crowded units have caused this crowding and created an uneasy environment. In the social and cultural dimension, we can also point to the existence of group conflicts and the lack of place belonging and the reduction of social trust in these areas. The results in the form of secondary categories of residents' social conflicts and overcrowding, lack of social and psychological security, lack of participation and institutional trust, and weak facilities and neglect of the spatial context show that the spatial nobility is not only not realized, but also creates instability for the residents. It has been determined. The analysis of the interviews in this dimension shows a window of issues that can be discussed with the secondary category of reducing social and psychological security in these areas. Due to many reasons, such as the existence of single people, drug addicts, busy families, etc., these areas have become unsafe and this has had the greatest impact on the lives of women and children. However, in relation to the related institutions, including the municipality, the analysis of the categories from the interviews shows that there is cooperation and trust between the residents and the institutions. burden What was discussed more about spatial justice is related to the weakness of facilities and neglect of the spatial context of these areas. Distance from health and treatment centers, disproportionate public transportation, lack of sports use, lack of green space and recreational use, and lack of waste management are the most important categories that show that the facilities of these areas are not sufficient to be able to have bio-sustainability in these areas. It is possible to affirm the existence of spatial justice and, to a greater extent, social justice.
Conclusion: urban services in its general sense can compensate for many service and public activities needed to manage urban affairs in these areas and reduce social and economic injustices. Therefore, institutional attention and participation of relevant institutions in this field is the most important solution to promote spatial justice and increase urban ecology in these areas.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Abdali, Y., Nadizadeh Shorabeh, S., Razovian, M., & Ali Puri, E. (2019). Evaluation of residents' satisfaction with the quality of Mehr housing complexes (case study: Noorabad city), Environment preparation, 51, 44-61. (In persian).
Afsharnia, A., Zebardast, E., & Talachian, M. (2022). Explaining the concept of spatial justice in the implementation of comprehensive urban plans (Case study: Golpayegan city). Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR)9(4), 981-1008. doi: 10.22059/jurbangeo.2021.320480.1478. (In persian).
Bayat., A. & Nabovi Chashmi, A. (2022). Street politics: poor people's movement in Iran. 10th edition, Shirazeh Publishing House. (In persian).
Bramley, G., Dempsey, N., Power, S. & Brown, S (2006). What is Social Sustainability and how do our Existing Urban Forms Perform in Nurturing It? Paper Presented at the "Sustainable Communities and Green Future" Conference. Bartlett School of Planning. University College London. London.
Bret, B.; Gervais-Lambony, P.; Hancock, C.; Landy, F. (2010). Justices et Injustices Spatiales; Presses Univeritaires de Paris Ouest: Paris, France City Alliance, City without Slums.
Consulting Engineers for Tadbir Shahr (2006). Master Plan of Sanandaj City, Kurdistan Province Housing and Urban Planning Organization. (In persian).
Dadashpoor, H., & Rostami, F. (2011). Investigation and analysis of urban public services distribution from the perspective of spatial equity: The case of Yasuj City. Journal of Geography and Regional Development9(1), -. doi: 10.22067/geography.v9i16.11034. (In persian).
Daneshmehr, H., khani, S., & molasalimi, V. (2023). Social capital as a sustainable living environment among the residents of Mehr housing (Case study: Baharan Mehr housing, Sanandaj). Motaleate Shahri12(47), 91-104. doi: 10.34785/J011.2022.015. (In persian).
Dempsey, N., Bramley, G., Power, S., & Brown, C (2009). The Social Dimension of Sustainable Development: Defining Urban Social Sustainability. Sustainable Development, 19 (5), 289-300.
Dikec. M & Gilbert. L (2002). Right to the City, in the new Socialist Ethics, 13: 3.
Doviran, I., Kazemian Gh., Meshkini, A., Roknaddin Eftekhari, A.R., & Kalahrenia, B (2012). Urban Integrated Management in Samandhi; Informal settlements in the central cities of Iran.
Fainstein, S. (2014). The just city. International Journal of Urban Sciences, 18(1), 1-18.
Ghalibaf, M., et al. (2010). Spatial centralism and its effects on the physical expansion and spatial structure of the city (case study: Sanandaj city), Geographical Space, 10(32), 151-180. (In persian).
Gutwald, R.; Leßmann, O.; Masson, T.; Rauschmayer, F. (2014). A Capability Approach to Intergenerational Justice? Examining the Potential of Amartya Sen’s Ethics with Regard to Intergenerational Issues. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 15(4):1-14.
Habibi, K., Alizadeh, H., Moradi Masihi, V., Valid Baigi, S., & Vafaee, S. (2012). Analyzing The Social Justice in Spatial Structure of Sanandaj City. Armanshahr Architecture & Urban Development4(7), 103-112. (In persian).
Harvey, D. (2018). From the right to the city to rebel cities, translated by Khosro Kalantari and Parviz Sadaqat, Tehran: Aghat Publications. (In persian).
Hedayat, O. (2022). The Process of the Physical Spatial Development of Marginalization and the Formation of Land Disputes (Institutional Ethnography of Marginalization in the Isolated Area of Naysar Sanandaj City). Quarterly Journals of Urban and Regional Development Planning7(21), 121-159. doi: 10.22054/urdp.2022.65073.1398. (In persian).
Hoolachan., J. (2020). Making home? Permitted and prohibited place-making in youth homeless accommodation, Housing Studies, Published Online: 21 Oct2020.
Iran Statistics Center website. (2016). (In persian).
Kathleen, S., & Melissa F., Arrigoitia., M. & Christine., W. (2015). Social housing in Europe, European Policy Analysis, 17: 1-12.
Koch, M. (2024). Planning for justice: A value-based framework to help spatial planners develop just housing strategies in Dutch regions.
Kolachian, M. (2003). Solutions for realizing social security, collection of articles of the social security conference, Tehran: Deputy Social Security and Police Force Guidance. (In persian).
Marcotullio, P.J. (2001). Asian Urban Sustainability in the era of Globalization United Nation University, Institute of Advanced Studies, Tokyo, Japan.
Merrifield, A. (2006). Henri Lefebvre: A Critical Introduction, London & New York: Taylor & Francis.
Mohammadpour, A. (2013). Qualitative research method, anti-method, Tehran: Sociology Press. (In persian).
Naimi, K., & babaii aghdam, F. (2017). City and Spatial Justice; The Analysis of The Distribution of Urban Public Services In The 22 Areas of City Sanandaj. Geographical Planning of Space7(23), 173-186. (In persian).
Pacione, M) 2003.( Urban Environmental Quality and Human Well-Being a Social Geographical Perspective, Landscape and Urban Planning, Vol. 65, No. 1-2.
Rastgar, Y., & Mohammadi, F. (2019). The semantic implications of home among the residents of Mehrkhaneh housing as a problematic matter, Urban Sociological Studies, 10(36), 1-26. (In persian).
Saedi, M., Najafian, S., & Yusef Zamani, M. (2020). Investigating the infrastructure problems of Mehr housing projects in Sanandaj city (case study: Mehr Baharan housing project), the fourth technology development forum and the international conference on new findings of civil engineering, architecture and the construction industry of Iran (Ircivil2019). (In persian).
Sanandaj Municipality Audit Unit Statistics, Detailed Plan Revision. (2016). (In persian).
Shakoi, H. (1986). Social Geography of Cities, Tehran: Jihad Academic Press. (In persian).
Smith, Dorothy E (2004). Institutional Ethnography (an interview with Dorothy E. Smith), Oslo, Sosiologisk Tidsskrift Press.
Soja, E. (2009). The city and spatial justice. Justice Spat.
Tagvai, A. & Tajdar, R. (2009). An introduction to good urban governance in an analytical approach, Urban Management, 33, 45-58. (In persian).
Talen, Emily and l.Anselin. (1998). Assessing spatial Equity: An Evaluation of Measures of Accessibility to Public Play grounds, Environment and Planning A, Vol, 30 , No 1.
Tonon, G. (2016). Indicators of Quality of Life in Latin America; Social Indicators Research Series; Springer International Publishing AG: Basel, Switzerland.
Tsou, k., yu, Ting hang, Y., Lin c. (2005). An accessibility-based integrated measure of relative spatial equity in urban public facilities, cities, 22 (6): 424-435.
www.e-sanandaj.ir, 2022. (In persian).