Narrative Analysis of the Elites' View of the Development of Baneh and Marivan Commercial-Industrial Free Zone

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Kurdistan, Sanandaj, Iran.

2 PhD student in sociology, Department of Sociology, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Kurdistan, Sanandaj, Iran.

3 Master of Economics, Department of Economics, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Kurdistan. Sanandaj Iran.

Abstract

Objective: The development of commercial-industrial free zones on the border with the aim of creating bottom-up development and empowering border areas is on the agenda of governments; Therefore, by giving priority to this issue, the governments saw the development of the border areas in the promotion of cross-border trade from the path of the prosperity of commercial-industrial free zones. Kurdistan province has always experienced marginalization and underdevelopment in most of the development indicators during recent decades. This is despite the fact that due to its strategic location, Kurdistan has the appropriate capacity to invest in various commercial, commercial and industrial sectors, and correct and strategic management in this area could prevent problems and issues that affected by the current situation in the province and even in the west of the country. The unfavorable situation of economic development indicators in Kurdistan province, such as low economic welfare and per capita income, high unemployment rate, low employment in the industrial sector and the weakness of the industrial sector of the province have led to informal activities such as peddling and Kolberi in Kurdistan. Therefore, the development of cross-border trade through the realization of the commercial-industrial free zone can play an important role in solving the underdevelopment of Kurdistan. Therefore, emphasizing Harvey's theoretical concepts about trade and international trade and Weiner's analysis of the functions of the free trade zone, the purpose of this research is to analyze the narrative of the elites' view of the development of the free trade-industrial zone in border cities of Kurdistan province.
Method: In the current research, a qualitative approach has been adopted in order to deeply understand the topic. The method used in this approach is narrative analysis. Narrative analysis was chosen because the interviewees were mostly people who, despite having an academic background in related fields, were often residents of the target border cities or served as employees of government bodies in the mentioned cities. The technique of data collection is interviews with relevant experts as key informants (university professors and experts in the field of economics) in Kurdistan province until theoretical saturation is reached, which in the end is 12 people. Thematic narrative analysis method was used to analyze the interviews. In this method, based on the expertise of experts in the field of research, the necessary interviews were conducted and the topics obtained were coded in three categories, open concepts, selective themes, and key themes, referring to the Strauss and Corbin analysis method.
Results: The findings indicate the following key themes: the development of business relations, the development of economic infrastructure and capital circulation under the theme of selective economic/commercial opportunities and the themes of increasing economic dependence, market monopoly and intensifying the bubble; financial under the theme of selective economic/commercial threats; the themes of strengthening cultural commonality, strengthening regional cohesion and strengthening regional tourism under the selective theme of social/cultural opportunities and finally, the themes of influencing lifestyle, changing ethnic-ethical patterns and changing the population context of the regions under the selective theme of social/cultural threats.
Conclusion: The development of commercial-industrial free zones is in line with the decentralization of development and development from below, during which governments try to empower local areas (especially border and marginal areas) and by considering the ability Native capacities and capabilities have been developed productively so that they can help alleviate poverty in these target areas while meeting the needs of the first residents of these areas. Using border capacities in Kurdistan province is also in line with these assumed plans in order to create sustainable employment for border residents, prevent their tendency to smuggling and help economic, commercial and industrial growth and development in the border cities of the province. The results show that the realization of a commercial-industrial free zone in the cities of Baneh and Marivan requires, first of all, a serious modification of the related key infrastructures, proper supervision and the integration of the border dwellers. However, the realization of the activities of these areas is associated with opportunities and threats in various economic/commercial and social/cultural fields, which along with economic growth and development of employment and welfare in the border areas, as well as the development of cultural and social relations, it can be associated with potential threats such as integration into the global capitalist economy and lifestyle changes. But in general, it can be acknowledged that the operational realization of the free trade zone in Kurdistan province can be accompanied by a kind of rethinking in the social, cultural, economic and even political and security relations at the level of the province and even in the west and northwest of Iran. During it, the previous and traditional patterns and views of this region have been transformed and Kurdistan (especially the border cities), will enter a new phase of multiple relations and interactions.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Amin, S. (1974). Accumulation on a world scale. Monthly Review Press.
Andalib, A., & motavaf, S. (2009). Development and Security in Spatial Strategic Planing in Border Regions. The Monthly Scientific Journal of Bagh-e Nazar6(12), 57-76. (In persian).
Briceno, A. J. H., de Hurtado, S. Z., & Mora, J. U. M. (2021). Economic and commercial convergence in Latin America. How are these countries doing so far? Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 57, 239-250.
Dahmarde, N., Aliahmadi, N., & Ghaderi, A. (2019). Evaluating and Prioritizing the Free Trade Zones of the Country and Their Impact on the Economic Development of These Regions. Quarterly Journal of The Macro and Strategic Policies7(25), 108-123. doi: 10.32598/JMSP.7.1.108. (In persian).
Daneshmehr, H., khaleqpanah, K., & hedayat, O. (2020). Border development and the disappearance of capacities and opportunities of border communities, emphasizing the critique of border markets (Case study; Nanor border bazaars of Baneh, Khav and Mirabad counties of Marivan city). Social Development & Welfare Planning11(43), 241-278. doi:10.22054/qjsd.2020.53491.2011. (In persian).
Department of the Permanent Secretariat of SELA (2010). Influence of free trade zones on the production diversification and the international insertion of Latin American and Caribbean countries, The Press and Publications Department of the Permanent Secretariat of SELA, Caracas, Venezuela.
Eftekhari., R,. Vodjani Tehrani, H & Razini, E. (2008). evaluation and prioritization of Iran's free trade zones using the HADM method, space planning and preparation (Humanities Faculty), 13(3): 101-87. (In persian).
Ferguson, J. (1990). The anti-politics machine:“ development,” depoliticization, and bureaucratic power in Lesotho. U of Minnesota Press.
Haftel, Y.Z. (2013). Commerce and Institutions: Trade, Scope, and the design of regional economic organizations. The Review of International Organizations, 8, 389-414.
Haji Aghazadeh Roudsari, M & Sarbazgadim, S. (2020). The role of the capacities of the country's free and commercial zones in the development and implementation of economic diplomacy in order to attract foreign investors for the development of entrepreneurship, Islamic Humanities Studies Quarterly, 7(28), 57-65. (In persian).
Harvey, J. (2007). The new economy, translated by: Mohammad Baqer and Hadi Nobakht, Tehran, second edition, Strategic Research Institute Publications. (In persian).
Haywood, R.C. (2004). Ecvonomic Realities and Free Trade Zones. 4.
https://www.amar.org.ir (2020). (In persian).
Inan, Süleyman (2005); Serbest Bölge Đthalat ve Đhracat Uygulamaları, www.alarko-carrier.com.tr.
Karimi, I. (2016). Designing an optimal business model for commercial-industrial free zones (case study: Baneh-Marivan commercial-industrial free zone), University of Science and Culture, Faculty of Human Sciences. (In persian).
Lotfi, E., Faizpour, M,. Yari, M., & Satar Rostami, H. (2015). Investigating the effect of socio-economic variables on crime in the country, the approach of combined techniques (a case study of robbery and murder), Police Management Research Journal, 11(3): 84-101. (In persian).
Newman, W. (2006). Methods of social research: quantitative and qualitative approaches, first volume, translated by Hasan Danaei Fard & Seyed Hossein Kazemi, 2015, Tehran, Mehraban Publishing Institute. (In persian).
Qadermarzi, M., Zaki, Y., Mahdi-zad, W., & Jamshidi, Y. (2018). Evaluation of effective components in the stability of security in border areas, research paper on order and security, 12(3): 101-123. (In persian).
Qolizadeh, S & Allahvardizadeh, A. (2007). The causes and consequences of goods smuggling in Iran after the Islamic revolution, Police Science Research, 12(49): 65-82. (In persian).
Rahimi Boroujerdi, A (2015). Economic Convergence: Regional Trade Arrangements and Common Markets, Tehran, First Edition, Samit Publications. (In persian).
Saedi, Y. (2021). Future research of commercial-industrial free zones in Kurdistan province, applied research center of Kurdistan province. (In persian).
Shakouri, A., & Omidi, H. (2018). An examination of the effect of Aras’s Free Zoon project on social welfare of the local community from dwellers’ point of view. Community Development (Rural and Urban)10(1), 49-74. doi: 10.22059/jrd.2018.68261. (In persian).
Shakuri, S., & Bonyadi naeini, A. (2016). scenarios Planning in the Future of technology in Application software with future study approach. Journal of Technology Development Management3(4), 111-138. doi: 10.22104/jtdm.2016.410. (In persian).
Simin, A. (2011). Investigating the Establishment of Regional-Trade Arrangement between Iran and neighboring countries (with land and water border). Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 5(11): 1942-1951.
Yaqubzadeh, R., Uncle, S., & Jan Babanjad, M. (2014). Evaluation of Iran's free zones in terms of tourist attraction and tourism infrastructure development; Case study: Qeshm Free Zone, Persian Gulf Cultural and Political Studies, 2(3): 58-74. (In persian).